At a Glance
| Dimension | Withings Body Comp | Withings Body+ | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Build & Display | 5 /5 | 4 /5 | Withings Body Comp |
| Measurement Depth | 5 /5 | 4 /5 | Withings Body Comp |
| App & Insights | 5 /5 | 5 /5 | Tie |
| Platform Compatibility | 4 /5 | 4 /5 | Tie |
| Value for Money | 3 /5 | 4 /5 | Withings Body+ |
Build & Display
Verdict: Withings Body Comp
Both use tempered glass platforms with flush stainless steel electrodes and an LED display strip, but the Body Comp's larger 40 × 31cm footprint and additional electrode array give it a more architectural, premium feel. The Body+ is well-built and visually clean, but is a clear step down in physical presence.
Measurement Depth
Verdict: Withings Body Comp
The Body+ covers four core metrics — body fat, muscle mass, bone mass, and water — which is enough for most people tracking general body composition trends. The Body Comp adds visceral fat mass, vascular age, and nerve health (electrodermal activity), three metrics not available from any other consumer scale, including the Body+.
App & Insights
Verdict: Tie
Both scales run on the same Health Mate app, which specifications and aggregated reviews consistently rank as the best smart scale companion app available. The Body Comp's app experience adds dedicated trend graphs for visceral fat and vascular age, but the underlying app quality — design, trend visualisation, data privacy practices — is identical.
Platform Compatibility
Verdict: Tie
Both scales offer the same strong Apple Health integration (weight, body fat, BMI, lean mass, water), the same basic Google Fit sync, and the same absence of native Garmin Connect support. There is no platform compatibility difference between the two — only the Body Comp's extra metrics do not extend to Apple Health or Google Fit either, since those platforms have no fields for visceral fat or vascular age.
Value for Money
Verdict: Withings Body+
At roughly half the price, the Body+ delivers the WiFi convenience, app quality, and multi-user recognition that make Withings scales worth buying — without the £90 premium for metrics most users will never look at twice. The Body Comp's value proposition depends entirely on whether visceral fat, vascular age, or nerve health are relevant to your specific health goals.
Two Scales, One App, One Real Decision
Strip away the marketing and the Body Comp and Body+ are closer than the price gap suggests. Same tempered glass construction. Same WiFi sync that uploads your weight before you have left the bathroom. Same Health Mate app, with its class-leading trend graphs and automatic anomaly detection. Same multi-user recognition, with the same occasional mix-up if two household members weigh within a few kilograms of each other.
The entire £90 difference comes down to three additional measurements on the Body Comp: visceral fat mass, vascular age, and nerve health via electrodermal activity. Everything else — design quality aside — is functionally the same product.
When the Extra Metrics Actually Matter
Visceral fat — the fat stored around your internal organs rather than under your skin — is independently associated with increased risk of type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and metabolic syndrome. Seeing this trend over months, alongside dietary or training changes, gives the Body Comp a genuine health-monitoring role that a weight-only scale cannot provide.
Vascular age and nerve health (via electrodermal activity) are similarly directional rather than diagnostic, but for anyone managing blood pressure, cholesterol, or diabetes-adjacent nerve function, they add a layer of data that no other consumer scale offers at any price.
The honest framing: if none of those three areas are part of how you currently think about your health, you will check those screens once, find them interesting, and then never look at them again. If any of them are part of how you manage your health, the Body Comp is the only consumer scale that tracks them at home.
Which Should You Choose?
If you are buying your first proper smart scale, or you simply want to track weight, body fat, and muscle mass over time without overspending — buy the Withings Body+. It delivers the WiFi convenience and app quality that make Withings worth choosing over a £40 budget scale, at a price that does not require justification.
If you are specifically managing metabolic health, cardiovascular risk, or diabetes-related concerns, and visceral fat or vascular age trends would genuinely change what you do day to day — the Body Comp is worth the premium, and nothing else in the consumer market matches it.
For most readers, the Body+ is the right starting point. The step up to the Body Comp is a deliberate choice for a specific health-monitoring need, not a general upgrade.
Overall Verdict
For most people, the Withings Body+ is the better buy. It shares the same WiFi sync, the same Health Mate app, and the same reliable multi-user recognition as the Body Comp, at roughly half the price. The Body Comp earns its £189.95 price tag only for a specific audience: anyone actively monitoring metabolic health, cardiovascular risk factors, or diabetes-adjacent nerve function, for whom visceral fat, vascular age, and nerve health data are genuinely useful additions rather than novelties.
Runner-up
Withings Body Comp
From £189.95
Winner
Withings Body+
From £99.95
Affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you
Who Should Buy Which?
Withings Body+
- You want accurate body fat, muscle mass, and hydration trends without overspending
- You are a first-time smart scale buyer upgrading from a basic bathroom scale
- You want the Health Mate app experience at the lower price point
Withings Body Comp
- You are managing metabolic health, blood pressure, or diabetes-related risk factors
- Visceral fat trend data is something you would actually act on
- You want the most analytically capable consumer scale regardless of price